If you or someone close to you was hurt by a dog, you’re likely wondering what the law says and how your rights stand. Laws around dog bites vary from state to state, and Pennsylvania has its own unique set of rules. These differences can shape the way your case is handled and the steps you’ll need to take next. Here’s what makes Pennsylvania’s dog bite laws stand out.
Pennsylvania Does Not Always Hold Dog Owners Strictly Liable
In some states, dog owners are always on the hook if their dog bites someone, no matter what. These are called “strict liability” states. But in Pennsylvania, it’s a little more complicated. A dog owner can be held responsible, but only in certain cases. If a dog has bitten before, or shown signs of aggression, the owner should have known the dog was dangerous. When that’s the case, the law says they’re liable.
But if the dog never showed signs of being dangerous, and the bite happened without warning, the owner might not be held fully responsible. The injured person would then have to prove that the owner was careless. That’s where the difference lies. In many other states, that step isn’t needed — the fact that a bite happened is enough.
Victims in Pennsylvania Might Only Get Medical Costs in Some Cases
Another thing that sets Pennsylvania apart is how damages are handled. If a dog bites someone but was never aggressive before, the law may limit what the victim can recover. In that situation, the owner might only have to pay for medical bills. That’s it. Pain, lost work, or emotional suffering might not be covered unless the victim proves the owner was careless.
Other states are more generous in this regard. Some allow bite victims to recover full damages — including pain and suffering — no matter the dog’s history. In Pennsylvania, you need to go a step further.
“Highly Recommended” is the epitome of an understatement when it comes to the firm of McDonald At Law!! Michael McDonald’s genuine pleasant, and empathetic demeanor masks his legal astuteness, and the level of aggressiveness he implements in pursuit of a victim’s right and the monetary compensation legally entitled to us. I was involved in a motor vehicle accident at the hands of an intoxicated driver in York County. In my case I suffered what I described as an atypical injury, Mr. McDonald offered to be my Lawyer immediately after explaining to him the events leading to and after being struck in turn causing me to have a heart attack, when another law firm seemed hesitant. McDonald At Law secured a sizable monetary compensation that not only met my expectation but exceeded it. Mr. McDonald’s wealth of experience, and legal prowess is priceless and never did he act as the case was beneath his practice. In the end my family and I were well compensated, but also felt justified. Thank you McDonald At Law!!- Miguel Lopez
There Is a Difference Between a “Dangerous Dog” and a Regular Dog
Pennsylvania law includes a category called a “dangerous dog.” If a dog has attacked someone before, or has tried to, and the act was not provoked, that dog might be labeled dangerous. Owners of such dogs have to follow strict rules. They need to register the dog, carry insurance, and secure the dog in a specific way.
If someone is bitten by a dog already marked as dangerous, the owner faces heavier penalties and is more likely to be held liable for all damages — not just medical costs. Many states don’t have this kind of classification or don’t enforce it as closely as Pennsylvania does.
The One-Bite Rule Doesn’t Fully Apply Here
Some states follow what’s called the “one-bite rule.” That means a dog gets one free pass. If it’s the first time the dog has ever bitten someone, the owner might not be held responsible. Pennsylvania mixes parts of this rule with others. In practice, this means that if a dog has never bitten or acted aggressively before, the owner might not face full liability — unless they acted carelessly in some way.
This middle-ground approach puts Pennsylvania between full strict liability states and full one-bite states. That makes understanding the dog’s history and the owner’s actions even more important in any dog bite case.
Putting off an Attorney due to Cost Choosing a Personal Injury AttorneyRelated Videos
Time Limits Matter in Pennsylvania
Like every state, Pennsylvania has a deadline for filing a dog bite lawsuit. Here, you have two years from the date of the bite to take legal action. That may sound like a long time, but building a case can take months. If you wait too long, you could lose your right to recover anything.
Some states give more time, and others less. In Pennsylvania, two years is the limit — and missing that deadline means your case is likely over before it starts.
Provocation and Trespassing Can Affect the Case
In Pennsylvania, if the person who was bitten was teasing the dog, hurting it, or trespassing, that can change everything. The law doesn’t favor someone who got bit after provoking the dog or entering private property without permission. In those cases, the owner might not be held responsible at all.
This is another area where state laws vary. Some states are more forgiving if someone was bitten after a small act of teasing. Pennsylvania tends to protect the dog owner more in those gray areas.
Why These Differences Matter for Your Case
If you were bitten by a dog in Pennsylvania, the laws here mean your case needs to be handled with care. You’ll need to gather information about the dog’s past, how the owner behaved, and what happened at the scene. Without these details, you could end up with only your medical costs covered — or nothing at all.
And if you were the dog’s owner and your dog bit someone, you need to know where you stand. Depending on your dog’s past and your actions, you might have a strong defense — or you might be facing full financial responsibility.
Verdicts & Settlements
Insurance Companies May Not Offer What You Deserve
After a dog bite, the first offer from the insurance company might seem helpful. But in Pennsylvania, where your recovery can depend on the dog’s history and owner’s actions, that first offer might leave out what you’re really owed. Insurance companies often try to settle quickly and for as little as possible. They may only offer coverage for medical bills and skip over the deeper pain, time off work, or the emotional toll you’re carrying. Accepting a quick settlement without fully understanding your rights could mean walking away from money you need to heal.
That’s one reason why it’s smart to talk to someone who knows this area of law. A good lawyer will ask the right questions, find out if the dog had a history, and make sure your injuries are fully documented. These details can shift your case from limited recovery to full recovery.
Children and Dog Bites Carry Extra Weight
When a child is bitten by a dog, Pennsylvania courts often treat the situation with greater seriousness. Children are less able to protect themselves, and their injuries may be deeper — physically and emotionally. If a dog attacked a child, the law may lean harder on the owner, especially if the dog had bitten before or was not kept under control. In these cases, families may recover more than just medical bills.
Still, even with children involved, the burden is on the family to prove that the owner failed in their duty. That’s where early evidence matters — photos, witness statements, and medical records can all strengthen the case.
When You Need Help, We’re Ready to Step In
At McDonald At Law, we’ve helped many people understand what Pennsylvania’s laws mean for their dog bite cases. Whether you were the one bitten or the dog’s owner, we can help you see what steps to take next. Let’s talk about your situation, and get clear on how the law works for you. Don’t wait too long. Time is short, and every detail matters.